Wednesday, June 12, 2024

The politics-religion overlap is murkier than Kellyanne Conway suggests

Related posts

Kellyanne Conway started a brand new job this week, showing on Fox Information as a paid contributor. It’s a very good match for Conway, who has at all times excelled at presenting punchy rhetorical factors on the fly. It’s additionally a very good match, after all, as a result of Conway has spent many of the previous six years deploying such factors in service of Donald Trump and his politics — exactly the kind of factor Fox Information viewers have grown accustomed to listening to.

On Tuesday night time, Conway appeared on Sean Hannity’s eponymous present. When Hannity requested whether or not Conway anticipated to see “a dramatic demographic shift this election,” she replied that she did — notably amongst Hispanics.

“Hispanics are realigning,” she stated, first pointing to financial concerns as a trigger. Then, she added, “they’re additionally very spiritual and so they see a Democratic Social gathering that’s overtly hostile to faith most days. They will’t even offer you ideas and prayers when there’s a tragedy. It’s solely ideas now.”

This isn’t an unusual argument. However it’s a very easy and, partially, an explicitly dishonest one.

Sign up for How To Read This Chart, a weekly data newsletter from Philip Bump

As a normal rule, it’s true that Hispanic and Black People usually tend to determine as Christian and fewer prone to say they don’t have any spiritual id than White People. Information from the biannual General Social Survey (GSS) reveals that over the previous twenty years, spiritual id as Christian has waned throughout racial teams and rejection of spiritual id has elevated. You possibly can see this within the two graphs within the left-hand column, under.

Conway’s level, although, is centered on the right-hand column. Democrats usually tend to reject faith than Republicans — if we’re speaking about White Democrats. Non-White Democrats determine alongside spiritual strains about the identical approach that White Republicans do. There weren’t sufficient Black and Hispanic Republicans included within the survey to indicate on the graph, which says one thing by itself.

This is just one measure of faith, after all. The GSS additionally asks about spiritual attendance the place, once more, we see that Whites are least prone to say they attend spiritual providers commonly.

However that’s largely as a result of White Democrats are a lot much less doubtless to take action. White Republicans attend spiritual providers at about the identical charge as Black Democrats.

So ought to we assume that Black People will equally “realign” with Republicans? Effectively, no, as a result of we perceive that the spiritual traditions between these teams are largely dissimilar and since we acknowledge that there are different historic causes that Black People align with the Democratic Social gathering. Church attendance, actually, doubtless reinforces that alignment.

What these graphs are reinforcing, actually, is that the excellence between spiritual identities may be as necessary as the excellence between spiritual and nonreligious. On the outset, we thought of spiritual id by the lens of Christianity, as a result of when Conway talks about faith she’s speaking in regards to the explicit model of faith that’s most typical in her social gathering. When she talks in regards to the left’s purported “hostility” to faith, she’s speaking about conflicts rooted in how her allies suppose faith must be practiced and manifested.

There are broad variations in how totally different spiritual teams overlap with political preferences. Pew Analysis Heart matched voter recordsdata with polling to find out how spiritual identification associated to voting within the 2018 midterm elections. It was a broadly Democratic-friendly election, but when we examine the margin amongst spiritual teams to the nationwide margin, we get a way of the unfold.

The margin amongst White evangelical Protestants was 73 factors extra Republican than the nationwide margin. Amongst White Catholics, it was 29 factors extra Republican. Amongst Hispanic Catholics, although, it was 35 factors extra Democratic. Amongst Black Protestants, it was 80 factors extra Democratic.

There was a shift to the precise amongst each Blacks and Hispanics in 2020, as Pew’s knowledge paperwork. However the gaps above are broad. If White Catholics and Hispanic Catholics deviate by 64 factors of their nationwide vote margin, that means fairly strongly that there are different pulls on political alternative in addition to merely spiritual id. A 3rd of Trump’s help in 2020 got here from evangelicals, in line with Pew, a bunch with a really particular view of faith and faith’s function in society that’s not shared even by different Christians.

Conway’s definitely proper, although, that some Hispanics are more and more selecting to vote Republican. Texas Month-to-month’s Jack Herrera wrote an excellent assessment of the shift within the southern a part of that state in 2020. To oversimplify, the suggestion from Herrera’s article is that spiritual id is a subset of cultural adjustments which are affecting vote alternative. This doesn’t battle with Conway’s evaluation, essentially; it’s only a totally different focus.

The main focus deployed by Conway is unsubtle. That Democrats are “overtly hostile” to faith will doubtless come as a shock to the heavy majority of Democrats who’re spiritual, together with White Democrats. It’ll come as a shock to President Biden, a working towards Catholic who makes a degree of attending service every week — and who defeated Conway’s boss in 2020, a president whose journeys to church buildings had been inseparable from politics. Her instance is that Democrats object to the phrase “ideas and prayers,” which, after all, will not be an objection to praying however to Republican reliance on the phrase as a response to mass capturing occasions.

That is one cause Conway is so good at what she does. She is aware of the info, definitely; her background is in polling. She’s adept at utilizing factual factors as a leaping off level for rhetorical ones. Like that Hispanics are extra spiritual than (White) Democrats — ergo, they are going to be turned off by the purported anti-religious tendencies of the left.

No marvel Fox Information wished to carry her onboard.

Next Post